Not cool, ECUSA.
Seriously: NOT COOL.
A popular priest known as “Father Oprah” has left the Roman Catholic Church and joined the Episcopal Church less than a month after a tabloid published photos of him cavorting on the beach with his girlfriend in a scandal that rocked South Florida’s Spanish-speaking community.
On Thursday, as thunder boomed outside and paparazzi cameras flashed, the Rev. Alberto Cutie (KOO’-tee-ay) held a news conference at the pulpit of the Episcopal Church’s Trinity Cathedral. Standing behind him: the Episcopal bishop, a half-dozen Episcopal priests and his girlfriend.
This story incites a sputtering, screaming, throwing-things-at-walls rage in me. Why? NOT because a priest fell in love and had a secret affair. People are people, no one is without sin. No one. This includes clergy. I’m not mad that Rev. Cutie is leaving the Catholic Church and becoming an Episcopal priest - um, it seems to be the logical thing to do since he doesn’t want to give up his vocation OR his relationship with his girlfriend. What makes me OMFG PISSED OFF is that the Episcopal Church seems to have welcomed him with open arms and without condition. Sure, he has to jump through some hoops to be an “official” Episcopal priest, but it appears that the ECUSA is going to let him pastor a new congregation without asking him to take a time out from ministry at all.
NOT. COOL.
The issue here is not sex. It’s the breaking of vows. It’s the betrayal of trust. It’s the secrecy, the lying. It’s the fact that Cutie lived a double life for TWO YEARS and when he was caught by a tabloid and taken to task by his spiritual authorities (his “boss,” if you will), he flounced to another denomination instead of humbly saying, “Dayum, I messed up.”
Something that may not be understood by people who aren’t part of a Christian community: a pastor has a lot of influence, and power, over the people in his* church. Sometimes his influence extends beyond his church to other churches in his area (if he serves on denominational or ecumenical committees, for example), and to unchurched people in his community/nation (if his church does outreach, say, in the form of soup kitchens, clothing drives, or educational reform). When a man chooses to violate the vows that he took when he became a priest, he is not only sinning against God, he’s betraying ALL the people he committed to serve, all the people he’s instructed and counseled over the years. And he needs to make amends.
But that’s not what Cutie is doing. He’s unwilling to say, “You know, my bad judgment shows that I’m not in a place to help other people right now. Once I get my head on straight, I’ll BRB.” Because he’s clueless, someone else needs to smack some sense into him. Unfortunately, the Episcopal Church (which, by the way, is the denomination I served in for five years, and I love them dearly, but they can be so full of FAIL sometimes) is asleep at the wheel. The ECUSA has recently seen a dramatic drop in church attendance as well as a decline in new priests entering the ministry. Many Episcopal congregations across the country have NO PASTOR because there’s a huge shortage of clergy. Of course I don’t know the whole story behind Cutie’s conversion (disclaimer alert!), but I have a sneaking suspicion that the Episcopal Church’s lack of judgment has a whole lot to do with their desperation to fill pulpits and pews. And that is NOT. COOL.
Now, don’t get me wrong. I’m not saying that making a Big Mistake disqualifies anyone from ministry. I’m not saying that it’s wrong for a pastor to be married (or, for that matter, gay - which I have to mention because The Gay Episcopal Bishop Debacle caused my Diocese to implode a few years ago). What I’m saying is that it’s wrong for someone to be so arrogant as to assume that his sneaky, selfish actions have no impact on the people he promised to serve in humility and purity.
NOT. COOL.
* There are many women pastors/priests in Christian denominations around the world, including the Episcopal Church. When discussing pastors/priests in this post, I’ve chosen to use only male pronouns for the sake of simplicity, and because the priest in question is a male.
Just to warn y’all, I really enjoyed this book, so my review of it could spill onto the annoying side of enthusiastic. Okay? Think you can handle it? If you say so…
Thankfully, I found something that enabled me to be creative and holy: prayer. I prayed every day and in every way, and in that communion with God I found purpose AND beauty. For Christmas 1999, a friend gave me a small, spiral-bound notebook - purple, with little sheep doodled on the front - and I discovered prayer journaling. My relationship with God seemed to be unraveling at the time - mostly because my pastor accused me of being treacherous and sinful - so I clung to prayer as a way to save me, and that little notebook was a life raft. Everything I thought and felt was formed into words, altars marking my journey. Over the years that followed, I made a practice of journaling daily, and found that those hours I spent in solitude with God and my words were essential to my well-being. This is how I managed to stay sane through confusion of The Cult, and a large part of why I still love God despite the abuse I suffered. Somehow, in the bombed-out wasteland of my soul, something small and beautiful managed to take seed and grow.
I learned, again, anew, how to meditate with words. This is why I write. 





